主管:教育部
主办:中国人民大学
ISSN 1002-8587  CN 11-2765/K
国家社科基金资助期刊

journal6 ›› 2010, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (3): 34-50.

• 学术专论 • 上一篇    下一篇

青年戴震:十八世纪中国士人社会的“局外人”与儒学的新动向

  

  1. 美国圣塔克鲁兹加州大学历史系、中国人民大学清史研究所
  • 出版日期:2010-08-15 发布日期:2010-08-15

Young Dai Zhen as An Outsider of Polite Society of Eighteen-century China

  • Online:2010-08-15 Published:2010-08-15

摘要: 本文从文化史的视角,分析青年戴震的经学方法论的形成。首先探讨商人与科考的大背景,说明戴震的边缘性格。戴震采取了极不寻常的字书方法,掌握了解读经典的原创方法。青年戴震于十年之间(1740—1750)发展出了一套字词学,专门的经学知识方法论,以及对于经典研究的整体评价的系统,并将其总结于《与是仲明论学书》中。本文对这一关键文本进行双向历史解读:读者是镜的历史脉络分析以及作者戴震的方法论系统分析。结论强调戴震方法论的客观性已超越其时代,并反思检讨了青年戴震学术形成的几种诠释。

Abstract: In this paper I reconsider young Dai Zhen as outsider of Eighteenth-century China and provide a revisionist account for the dynamics of mid-Qing Confucianism. The first section,“Merchant and Examination”,introduces the avenues of social mobility for Huizhou merchants in the system of elementary education and civil service examinations. Dai Zhen was cast as an outsider to this largely exclusive system and appeared to be incapable of succeeding in it. In the second section, “Overcoming Classical Literacy”, I describe how Dai Zhen chose to pursue, against overwhelming odds,elites status and knowledge,and how he acquired classical literacy by his own efforts. In the third section, “Engaging Literati Sociability”,I describe in detail the politics and sociability of Shi Jing (1693- 1769),who embodied a residual form of Ming dynasty Donglin Activism. Here I will show how Dai Zhen attempted to take part in the unpredictable dynamics of sociability among members of the national elite. In the forth and final section,“Technical Methodology for Classical Studies”,I identify the intellectual proposal that emerged from Dai Zhen's engagement with Shi Jing. The proposal,embodied in this epistolary document,proves to be the key for understanding what had propelled Dai Zhen to this point in 1750 and what he would continue pursue afterwards.